Medieval historical records and medical texts reveal that historical approaches to mental health and emotional well-being shared unexpected similarities with modern preventive healthcare, according to archival research from medieval treatises and personal correspondence.
Demonic Possession Versus Medical Reality in the 12th Century
While religious texts frequently attributed mental health struggles to demonic possession, research into medieval medical writings shows a more sophisticated framework for understanding mental wellness, according to historical analyses of period health guides.
Humoral Medicine and Emotional Regulation in Medieval Regimens
Medical writing from the period established that mental wellness sat at the core of a healthy lifestyle through the dominant humoral system, which sought to balance blood, phlegm, black bile, and yellow bile, according to late-medieval European regimens. Popular how-to health books warned individuals to control their emotions to protect their physical bodies.
The Physical Toll of Fear, Anger, and High Responsibility
Certain intense emotions were believed to cause sudden physical ailments or death, according to medical and chronicle sources. Fear could freeze the blood around the heart, as recorded in the 12th-century miracle collections of St James at Reading Abbey regarding an Essex clerk’s daughter named Alice who suffered a temporary fit of mania after seeing a ghost. Chronic anger was said to ‘consume the body swiftly, so that the man meets a short end,’ according to a mid-15th-century German regimen. High-status men and individuals under constant pressure, such as master craftsmen or busy knights like Boucicaut, faced severe mental strain, with contemporary conduct books noting that pressing worries ‘gnaw at his gut.’
Did You Know?
Monks such as Matthew of Rievaulx and Alexander de Langley suffered physical exhaustion, stomach pains, and mental breakdowns attributed directly to heavy administrative workloads and excessive study.
Melancholy, Anxiety, and Monastic Acedia
Anxiety and persistent low mood plagued figures like the Tuscan merchant Francesco Datini (c. 1335–1410), who wrote to his wife Margherita that he felt ‘so vexed by many matters, it is a wonder I am not out of my mind.’ Melancholia, characterized by persistent low mood and terrifying visions, affected high-ranking individuals including King Duarte of Portugal (1391–1438), who documented his lifelong struggle with a ‘melancholic humour.’ Monks were also considered particularly vulnerable to acedia, a state of spiritual and mental exhaustion leaving them feeling half-dead, according to monastic records.
Holistic Treatments and Lifestyle Prescriptions
Physicians treated melancholia by addressing underlying physical humoral imbalances—often prescribing syrups made with warming ingredients like cinnamon and liquorice, or warm oil massages—combined with lifestyle changes akin to modern social prescriptions. When Taddeo Alderotti treated Obizzo II d’Este for melancholy and insomnia, his prescription included taking walks, seeing beautiful things, and listening to preferred music. Historical sources also note that mood-altering substances like saffron, oregano, and fennel were widely believed to provoke joy, while Abbess Hildegard of Bingen (1098–1179) recommended looking at an onyx stone to cease mental oppression.
Pro Tips for Mental Well-being from Medieval Texts
- Engage with the arts: Listening to stories and music was actively prescribed by medieval authorities, such as in 1390s Bologna, to restore weak hearts to deep joy.
- Spending time outdoors: Taking long walks in green landscapes provided physical, mental, and spiritual benefits by exposing individuals to wholesome air, according to 15th-century medical writer John Mirfield.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did medieval people view mental health issues as modern medical conditions?
No. While they understood the mind-body connection through the humoral system and recognized conditions like melancholia, they frequently attributed extreme psychological episodes to supernatural causes like demonic possession, or physical imbalances of black bile.
What treatments did medieval doctors use for depression and anxiety?
Physicians utilized dietary adjustments, herbal remedies containing saffron or cinnamon, warm oil massages, and lifestyle modifications such as outdoor exercise, listening to music, viewing pleasant art, and spending time in gardens.
Were mental health struggles common among high-status individuals in the Middle Ages?
Yes. Historical records show that merchants like Francesco Datini, monarchs like King Duarte of Portugal, and busy knights experienced severe anxiety, stress, and melancholia due to heavy responsibilities and intense workloads.
Exploring Historical Perspectives on Mental Health
Examining the lived experiences of historical figures demonstrates that conditions like anxiety and depression are enduring human challenges rather than modern inventions. Emulating the historical emphasis on preventive medicine, holistic lifestyle management, and emotional resilience offers valuable lessons for contemporary society. Explore our archives for more articles on the intersection of history, health, and society, and subscribe to our newsletter for weekly updates.
Worth a look